Thomas Greene reviews SP2 for Windows XP in characteristically inflammatory style over at the Register and comes up with the startling conclusion that
Microsoft declined many opportunities to harden Windows XP in a meaningful way; that is, by disabling unnecessary services, enforcing the multiuser environment, setting sensible user and file permissions, and installing a fully-functional packet filter. The roster of missing security utilities, such as PGP, SSH, a proper wipe utility, etc., is immense.
There's no shortage of valid points in this review, but the major niggling point for me can be quite easily illustrated by selectively quoting and adding my own emphasis, like this:
We evaluated the security features of Windows XP SP2 on a test machine, following a clean install of XP Pro with no configuration changes and no third-party software or drivers installed.
DHCP Client, automatic. Unnecessary on most home machines. Should be disabled by default.
DNS Client, automatic. Unnecessary on most home machines. Should be disabled by default.
NetMeeting Remote Desktop Sharing, manual. Unnecessary on most home machines. Should be disabled by default.
It's been a while since I've used XP, and for that matter, it's been even longer since I've used XP Home (the crucial word there is "home", a subtle implication that that version of the OS is to be used in a home computing environment) seeing as I've never installed that OS on any machine I've regularly used.
Having said that, I'm pretty sure that there's a whole raft of services here that XP Pro enables, whether either setting them as manual or automatic that might not be in XP Home. At the very least, I'm pretty convinced that Remote Desktop Connection is a feature that's only available in XP Pro (and is one of the main reasons why I prefer that OS). See, what's annoying is that so many of these criticisms are levelled as being unsuitable for a home computer operating system when XP Pro isn't. Home is to Windows 9x as Pro is to NT/2000 - reviewing a business desktop OS using home user criteria seems a little disingenuous to say the least. Besides, there's so much more to validly critique Windows XP -- Pro or Home without having to do a bait-and-switch.
41 comments and trackbacks
You weren't the only one to say that, which is why two weeks later he reviewed XP Home as well.
Posted by: Nick on September 23, 2004 10:02 AM
Ah, you strip the URI: http://www.theregister.co.uk/2004/09/17/xphome_sp2/
Posted by: Nick on September 23, 2004 10:03 AM
You can also take a look at some information in the field of strip poker strip poker http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/strip-poker.html poker rules poker rules http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/poker-rules.html free poker free poker http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/free-poker.html poker hands poker hands http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/poker-hands.html party poker party poker http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/party-poker.html poker games poker games http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/poker-games.html how to play poker how to play poker http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/how-to-play-poker.html learn to play poker learn to play poker http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/learn-to-play-poker.html online poker game online poker game http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/online-poker-game.html poker forum poker forum http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/poker-forum.html free poker game free poker game http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/free-poker-game.html longest poker game longest poker game http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/longest-poker-game.html free rules for poker free rules for poker http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/free-rules-for-poker.html play free poker play free poker http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/play-free-poker.html poker hand poker hand http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/poker-hand.html omaha poker omaha poker http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/omaha-poker.html go play poker go play poker http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/go-play-poker.html winning poker hands winning poker hands http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/winning-poker-hands.html free poker game download free poker game download http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/free-poker-game-download.html poker download poker download http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/poker-download.html caribbean stud poker caribbean stud poker http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/caribbean-stud-poker.html 3 card poker 3 card poker http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/3-card-poker.html stud poker stud poker http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/stud-poker.html basic rules of poker basic rules of poker http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/basic-rules-of-poker.html poker strip poker strip http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/poker-strip.html gambling poker gambling poker http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/gambling-poker.html yahoo poker yahoo poker http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/yahoo-poker.html poker rule poker rule http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/poker-rule.html hold em hold em http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/hold-em.html party poker bonus code party poker bonus code http://www.lilaleemcrightrealty.com/party-poker-bonus-code.html - Tons of interesdting stuff!!!
Posted by: official poker rules on June 18, 2005 01:11 PM
Please take a look at the pages about poker rules poker rules http://poker-rules.zindagi.us/ ...
Posted by: poker rules on June 20, 2005 10:27 PM
Please check the sites dedicated to free poker free poker http://www.poker-adventure.com/free-poker.html ... Thanks!!!
Posted by: free poker on June 21, 2005 06:18 AM
Please check out some relevant information about internet casino internet casino http://www.scottishtutors.com/internet-casino.html - Tons of interesdting stuff!!!
Posted by: internet casino on June 22, 2005 05:11 AM
You are invited to visit some relevant information on world series of poker world series of poker http://www.wow-poker.com/world-series-of-poker.html poker and chip poker and chip http://www.wow-poker.com/poker-and-chip.html poker gifts poker gifts http://www.wow-poker.com/poker-gifts.html party poker bonus code party poker bonus code http://www.wow-poker.com/party-poker-bonus-code.html poker star poker star http://www.wow-poker.com/poker-star.html stud poker stud poker http://www.wow-poker.com/stud-poker.html poker card game poker card game http://www.wow-poker.com/poker-card-game.html poker terms poker terms http://www.wow-poker.com/poker-terms.html partypoker bonus code partypoker bonus code http://www.wow-poker.com/partypoker-bonus-code.html basic rules of poker basic rules of poker http://www.wow-poker.com/basic-rules-of-poker.html home poker games home poker games http://www.wow-poker.com/home-poker-games.html holdem poker texas tip holdem poker texas tip http://www.wow-poker.com/holdem-poker-texas-tip.html rules playing poker rules playing poker http://www.wow-poker.com/rules-playing-poker.html rank of poker hands rank of poker hands http://www.wow-poker.com/rank-of-poker-hands.html holdem rule holdem rule http://www.wow-poker.com/holdem-rule.html palm one and texas hold palm one and texas hold http://www.wow-poker.com/palm-one-and-texas-hold.html online poker affiliate online poker affiliate http://www.wow-poker.com/online-poker-affiliate.html holdem scranton holdem scranton http://www.wow-poker.com/holdem-scranton.html taxes holdem taxes holdem http://www.wow-poker.com/taxes-holdem.html win 7 card stud win 7 card stud http://www.wow-poker.com/win-7-card-stud.html online holdem inspector 215 crack online holdem inspector 215 crack http://www.wow-poker.com/online-holdem-inspector-215-crack.html online poker betting online poker betting http://www.wow-poker.com/online-poker-betting.html online poker bonus codes online poker bonus codes http://www.wow-poker.com/online-poker-bonus-codes.html partypoker warez partypoker warez http://www.wow-poker.com/partypoker-warez.html freeware hold em calculator xp freeware hold em calculator xp http://www.wow-poker.com/freeware-hold-em-calculator-xp.html freeware texas hold freeware texas hold http://www.wow-poker.com/freeware-texas-hold.html gabling chips for 5 card stud gabling chips for 5 card stud http://www.wow-poker.com/gabling-chips-for-5-card-stud.html 5 card stud poker 5 card stud poker http://www.wow-poker.com/5-card-stud-poker.html download em game hold poker download em game hold poker http://www.wow-poker.com/download-em-game-hold-poker.html wsop gold bracelet wsop gold bracelet http://www.wow-poker.com/wsop-gold-bracelet.html ... Thanks!!!
Posted by: poker party on June 23, 2005 09:53 AM
Please check some relevant information about world series of poker world series of poker http://www.uclaaud.org/world-series-of-poker.html free online poker free online poker http://www.uclaaud.org/free-online-poker.html poker table poker table http://www.uclaaud.org/poker-table.html world poker tour world poker tour http://www.uclaaud.org/world-poker-tour.html video poker video poker http://www.uclaaud.org/video-poker.html free texas hold em free texas hold em http://www.uclaaud.org/free-texas-hold-em.html free poker games free poker games http://www.uclaaud.org/free-poker-games.html how to play poker how to play poker http://www.uclaaud.org/how-to-play-poker.html poker hand rankings poker hand rankings http://www.uclaaud.org/poker-hand-rankings.html celebrity poker celebrity poker http://www.uclaaud.org/celebrity-poker-.html - Tons of interesdting stuff!!!
Posted by: free texas hold em on June 24, 2005 12:38 PM
Take your time to take a look at some helpful info on texas hold em site texas hold em site http://www.poker-stadium.com/texas-hold-em.html party poker site party poker site http://www.poker-stadium.com/party-poker.html poker rooms site poker rooms site http://www.poker-stadium.com/poker-rooms.html ... Thanks!!!
Posted by: empire poker site on June 25, 2005 11:43 PM
You may find it interesting to take a look at some information in the field of loans loans http://www.24hours-credit.com/loans.html home loans home loans http://www.24hours-credit.com/home-loans.html payday loans payday loans http://www.24hours-credit.com/payday-loans.html home equity loan home equity loan http://www.24hours-credit.com/home-equity-loan.html payday loan payday loan http://www.24hours-credit.com/payday-loan.html refinance refinance http://www.24hours-credit.com/refinance.html personal loans personal loans http://www.24hours-credit.com/personal-loans.html debt consolidation loan debt consolidation loan http://www.24hours-credit.com/debt-consolidation-loan.html payday advance payday advance http://www.24hours-credit.com/payday-advance.html credit card offers credit card offers http://www.24hours-credit.com/credit-card-offers.html ... Thanks!!!
Posted by: credit card offers on June 26, 2005 08:10 AM
Please check some information about world series of poker world series of poker http://www.greats-poker.com/world-series-of-poker.html free online poker free online poker http://www.greats-poker.com/free-online-poker.html poker table poker table http://www.greats-poker.com/poker-table.html world poker tour world poker tour http://www.greats-poker.com/world-poker-tour.html video poker video poker http://www.greats-poker.com/video-poker.html free texas hold em free texas hold em http://www.greats-poker.com/free-texas-hold-em.html free poker games free poker games http://www.greats-poker.com/free-poker-games.html how to play poker how to play poker http://www.greats-poker.com/how-to-play-poker.html poker hand rankings poker hand rankings http://www.greats-poker.com/poker-hand-rankings.html celebrity poker celebrity poker http://www.greats-poker.com/celebrity-poker-.html - Tons of interesdting stuff!!!
Posted by: free poker games on June 26, 2005 05:10 PM
In your free time, check the sites in the field of blackjack blackjack http://www.epraha.info/blackjack.html .
Posted by: casino on June 28, 2005 12:31 AM
Take your time to take a look at the sites about loans loans http://www.highest-credit.com/loans.html home loans home loans http://www.highest-credit.com/home-loans.html payday loans payday loans http://www.highest-credit.com/payday-loans.html home equity loan home equity loan http://www.highest-credit.com/home-equity-loan.html payday loan payday loan http://www.highest-credit.com/payday-loan.html refinance refinance http://www.highest-credit.com/refinance.html personal loans personal loans http://www.highest-credit.com/personal-loans.html debt consolidation loan debt consolidation loan http://www.highest-credit.com/debt-consolidation-loan.html payday advance payday advance http://www.highest-credit.com/payday-advance.html credit card offers credit card offers http://www.highest-credit.com/credit-card-offers.html .
Posted by: payday loans on June 28, 2005 05:43 PM
You are invited to visit some relevant information about empire poker empire poker http://www.allabout-poker.net/empire-poker.html poker games poker games http://www.allabout-poker.net/poker-games.html poker poker http://www.allabout-poker.net/poker.html party poker party poker http://www.allabout-poker.net/party-poker.html pacific poker pacific poker http://www.allabout-poker.net/pacific-poker.html poker rooms poker rooms http://www.allabout-poker.net/poker-rooms.html online poker online poker http://www.allabout-poker.net/online-poker.html - Tons of interesdting stuff!!!
Posted by: empire poker on June 29, 2005 02:57 PM
In your free time, visit some relevant information in the field of online pharmacies online pharmacies http://www.allkinds-pills.com/online-pharmacies.html http://www.allkinds-pills.com/online-pharmacies.html canadian pharmacy canadian pharmacy http://www.allkinds-pills.com/canadian-pharmacy.html http://www.allkinds-pills.com/canadian-pharmacy.html pill identification pill identification http://www.allkinds-pills.com/pill-identification.html http://www.allkinds-pills.com/pill-identification.html prescription drugs prescription drugs http://www.allkinds-pills.com/prescription-drugs.html http://www.allkinds-pills.com/prescription-drugs.html propecia propecia http://www.allkinds-pills.com/propecia.html http://www.allkinds-pills.com/propecia.html - Tons of interesdting stuff!!!
Posted by: propecia on July 4, 2005 08:02 AM
You may find it interesting to check out the sites about protonix protonix http://www.allkinds-pills.com/protonix.html http://www.allkinds-pills.com/protonix.html hair loss treatment hair loss treatment http://www.allkinds-pills.com/hair-loss-treatment.html http://www.allkinds-pills.com/hair-loss-treatment.html diabetes medication diabetes medication http://www.allkinds-pills.com/diabetes-medication.html http://www.allkinds-pills.com/diabetes-medication.html augmentin augmentin http://www.allkinds-pills.com/augmentin.html http://www.allkinds-pills.com/augmentin.html celexa celexa http://www.allkinds-pills.com/celexa.html http://www.allkinds-pills.com/celexa.html - Tons of interesdting stuff!!!
Posted by: zithromax on July 4, 2005 03:05 PM
Posted by: blackjack on July 5, 2005 01:36 AM
You may find it interesting to visit some relevant information in the field of empire poker empire poker http://www.lizscottrawson.com/empire-poker.html http://www.lizscottrawson.com/empire-poker.html .
Posted by: poker games on July 5, 2005 05:38 AM
starting a day care
home day care
Posted by: child daycare on July 12, 2005 06:03 PM
Posted by: movies on July 12, 2005 06:07 PM
bass fishing tips
bass fishing secrets
learn to fish
how to fish
Posted by: bass fishing tips on July 13, 2005 02:09 AM
free golf tips
golf instruction guide
Posted by: golf instruction guide on July 13, 2005 03:05 PM
people finder free
Posted by: people finder on July 13, 2005 03:06 PM
You may find it interesting to check out the pages about poker party reload bonus poker party reload bonus http://www.sportscribe.com/poker-party.html http://www.sportscribe.com/poker-party.html - Tons of interesdting stuff!!!
Posted by: party poker in tools on July 14, 2005 02:09 AM
You can also check some relevant information on poker poker http://www.yachtdurak.com/poker.html http://www.yachtdurak.com/poker.html poker games poker games http://www.yachtdurak.com/poker-games.html http://www.yachtdurak.com/poker-games.html pacific poker pacific poker http://www.yachtdurak.com/pacific-poker.html http://www.yachtdurak.com/pacific-poker.html online poker online poker http://www.yachtdurak.com/online-poker.html http://www.yachtdurak.com/online-poker.html free poker free poker http://www.yachtdurak.com/free-poker.html http://www.yachtdurak.com/free-poker.html party poker party poker http://www.yachtdurak.com/party-poker.html http://www.yachtdurak.com/party-poker.html empire poker empire poker http://www.yachtdurak.com/empire-poker.html http://www.yachtdurak.com/empire-poker.html poker rules poker rules http://www.yachtdurak.com/poker-rules.html http://www.yachtdurak.com/poker-rules.html ... Thanks!!!
Posted by: pacific poker on July 14, 2005 01:34 PM
burn plus music
burn plus mp3
burn plus music downloads
burnplus music downloads
burn plus software
burn plus free
free burn plus
Posted by: burn plus free on July 15, 2005 01:42 AM
how to attract women
what women want
dating tips for men
Posted by: what women want on July 15, 2005 05:50 AM
Posted by: guitar on July 15, 2005 09:19 AM
used car prices
used cars for sale
used cars online
buying used cars
search for used cars
buy used cars
find used cars
buy a car
buy a used car
buy a new car
buy a car bad credit
how to buy a used car
buy a car online
used car search
new car search
used car classifieds
Posted by: used car search on July 15, 2005 09:45 AM
paid online survey
free paid survey
get paid for survey
Posted by: paid survey on July 15, 2005 10:41 AM
legal music download
Posted by: legal music download on July 15, 2005 10:54 AM
zoom teeth whitening
teeth whitening products
Posted by: cosmetic dentistry on July 15, 2005 12:58 PM
Posted by: online dating on July 15, 2005 01:54 PM
free lyrics search
Posted by: music lyrics on July 15, 2005 03:19 PM
Posted by: allergies on July 15, 2005 03:51 PM