Steven Johnson has a new article up on Slate about interface uniformity--that just maybe "one-fits-all" is not necessarily the best approach and sometimes just using the best tool for job may be better. Excerpt from the article:
[By] bundling iPhoto with OS X, Apple is basically saying: The desktop metaphor is great for certain types of files, but not for files that happen to be photos. Some types of data need a new kind of interface. But the fascinating possibility right now—and it's only a possibility—is that Microsoft's next major upgrade to Windows, code-named Longhorn, will move in the exact opposite direction. For some time now, rumor sites have been speculating about Longhorn's integrated database, designed to tie all your different types of data together under a unified interface.
The ultimate goal is to prevent you from having to learn entire new programs to interact with your mail messages, your contacts, and your home movies—to ensure that each data type doesn't become the exclusive province of a specific application. (To take an example from the iApps, iPhoto is great at organizing your photos, but it's useless if you're trying to figure out which snapshot you e-mailed to your mother last week.) Think about searching for text strings in four different contexts: in a Word document, in your inbox, on the Web, and in your hard drive. There are four distinct search tools for those four tasks, each with its own interface, each "belonging" to a different application. But in each case, you're just searching for text. Why use a Swiss army knife when one blade will do? As Bill Gates put it on Charlie Rose last month, "Right now when you use Windows, the way that you step through your photos, the way you step through your music, the way you step through e-mail or files, they're all different. You have to learn different user interfaces, different search commands. ... The idea of Longhorn is to have one approach, one set of commands that work for everything, including all of those things. And so the number of concepts you have to learn is dramatically less."
A big fan of Pinker, Steven says on his blog:
One interesting analogy here, which I'd originally included in the piece, is the way this struggle mirrors debates about the brain: is the brain a swiss-army-knife of specialized modules, or is it more of a general intelligence? The evidence right now certainly makes it seem like evolution selected the modular approach. It will be interesting to see if our interfaces follow a comparable path. [more]
31 comments and trackbacks
Take your time to check some relevant pages dedicated to poker games poker games http://www.norwichwriters.org/poker-games.html party poker party poker http://www.norwichwriters.org/party-poker.html pacific poker pacific poker http://www.norwichwriters.org/pacific-poker.html empire poker empire poker http://www.norwichwriters.org/empire-poker.html poker rules poker rules http://www.norwichwriters.org/poker-rules.html free poker free poker http://www.norwichwriters.org/free-poker.html poker poker http://www.norwichwriters.org/poker.html online poker online poker http://www.norwichwriters.org/online-poker.html ...
Posted by: online poker on June 20, 2005 05:23 AM
In your free time, check out the pages in the field of celebrity poker celebrity poker http://www.wow-poker.com/celebrity-poker.html poker tables for sale poker tables for sale http://www.wow-poker.com/poker-tables-for-sale.html omaha poker omaha poker http://www.wow-poker.com/omaha-poker.html online pai gow poker online pai gow poker http://www.wow-poker.com/online-pai-gow-poker.html play poker for free play poker for free http://www.wow-poker.com/play-poker-for-free.html go play poker go play poker http://www.wow-poker.com/go-play-poker.html live play poker live play poker http://www.wow-poker.com/live-play-poker.html play poker like the pros play poker like the pros http://www.wow-poker.com/play-poker-like-the-pros.html party poker million party poker million http://www.wow-poker.com/party-poker-million.html rules for poker rules for poker http://www.wow-poker.com/rules-for-poker.html seven card stud seven card stud http://www.wow-poker.com/seven-card-stud.html free holdem free holdem http://www.wow-poker.com/free-holdem.html texas hold poker texas hold poker http://www.wow-poker.com/texas-hold-poker.html holdem poker information holdem poker information http://www.wow-poker.com/holdem-poker-information.html history of seven card stud history of seven card stud http://www.wow-poker.com/history-of-seven-card-stud.html online holdem inspector 214 online holdem inspector 214 http://www.wow-poker.com/online-holdem-inspector-214.html online poker for macintosh online poker for macintosh http://www.wow-poker.com/online-poker-for-macintosh.html hold em odds chart hold em odds chart http://www.wow-poker.com/hold-em-odds-chart.html online poker secrets online poker secrets http://www.wow-poker.com/online-poker-secrets.html online poker site reviews online poker site reviews http://www.wow-poker.com/online-poker-site-reviews.html online game poker online game poker http://www.wow-poker.com/online-game-poker.html online poker room bonuses free hosting web online poker room bonuses free hosting web http://www.wow-poker.com/online-poker-room-bonuses-free-hosting-web.html online poker scholarships online poker scholarships http://www.wow-poker.com/online-poker-scholarships.html texan holdem texan holdem http://www.wow-poker.com/texan-holdem.html 1983 wsop champion 1983 wsop champion http://www.wow-poker.com/1983-wsop-champion.html hold em bot downloads hold em bot downloads http://www.wow-poker.com/hold-em-bot-downloads.html omaha hi poker rules omaha hi poker rules http://www.wow-poker.com/omaha-hi-poker-rules.html tournament tricks poker hold em tournament tricks poker hold em http://www.wow-poker.com/tournament-tricks-poker-hold-em.html five card stud poker shareware five card stud poker shareware http://www.wow-poker.com/five-card-stud-poker-shareware.html partypoker sign up bonus partypoker sign up bonus http://www.wow-poker.com/partypoker-sign-up-bonus.html ... Thanks!!!
Posted by: dog playing poker on June 22, 2005 04:25 PM
Take your time to check out the sites on world series of poker world series of poker http://www.dalin-ina.com/world-series-of-poker.html strip poker game strip poker game http://www.dalin-ina.com/strip-poker-game.html poker players poker players http://www.dalin-ina.com/poker-players.html caribbean stud poker caribbean stud poker http://www.dalin-ina.com/caribbean-stud-poker.html pot limit poker pot limit poker http://www.dalin-ina.com/pot-limit-poker.html las vegas poker tournaments las vegas poker tournaments http://www.dalin-ina.com/las-vegas-poker-tournaments.html free poker play free poker play http://www.dalin-ina.com/free-poker-play.html texas hold um texas hold um http://www.dalin-ina.com/texas-hold-um.html poker hand ranking poker hand ranking http://www.dalin-ina.com/poker-hand-ranking.html online poker reviews online poker reviews http://www.dalin-ina.com/online-poker-reviews.html online poker cheat online poker cheat http://www.dalin-ina.com/online-poker-cheat.html wsop hand ranking wsop hand ranking http://www.dalin-ina.com/wsop-hand-ranking.html online gay strip poker online gay strip poker http://www.dalin-ina.com/online-gay-strip-poker.html online poker bible online poker bible http://www.dalin-ina.com/online-poker-bible.html seven card stud rules seven card stud rules http://www.dalin-ina.com/seven-card-stud-rules.html daily holdem tournaments in las vegas daily holdem tournaments in las vegas http://www.dalin-ina.com/daily-holdem-tournaments-in-las-vegas.html odds at holdem odds at holdem http://www.dalin-ina.com/odds-at-holdem.html 7 card stud tournament 7 card stud tournament http://www.dalin-ina.com/7-card-stud-tournament.html binions wsop binions wsop http://www.dalin-ina.com/binions-wsop.html limit holdem odds chart limit holdem odds chart http://www.dalin-ina.com/limit-holdem-odds-chart.html online poker add a site online poker add a site http://www.dalin-ina.com/online-poker-add-a-site.html online poker room bonuses free hosting web online poker room bonuses free hosting web http://www.dalin-ina.com/online-poker-room-bonuses-free-hosting-web.html online poker submit a url online poker submit a url http://www.dalin-ina.com/online-poker-submit-a-url.html wsop on espn wsop on espn http://www.dalin-ina.com/wsop-on-espn.html harrington hold em harrington hold em http://www.dalin-ina.com/harrington-hold-em.html how to win at texas hold how to win at texas hold http://www.dalin-ina.com/how-to-win-at-texas-hold.html online 7 card stud online 7 card stud http://www.dalin-ina.com/online-7-card-stud.html wsop tryangle wsop tryangle http://www.dalin-ina.com/wsop-tryangle.html free poker seven card stud no download free poker seven card stud no download http://www.dalin-ina.com/free-poker-seven-card-stud-no-download.html partypoker cracked partypoker cracked http://www.dalin-ina.com/partypoker-cracked.html ...
Posted by: big als hold em on June 23, 2005 10:07 PM
Please check out some helpful info dedicated to casino casino http://www.baby-casino.com/casino.html online gambling online gambling http://www.baby-casino.com/online-gambling.html roulette roulette http://www.baby-casino.com/roulette.html .
Posted by: slot machines on June 25, 2005 04:13 PM
Take your time to visit some relevant pages in the field of world series of poker world series of poker http://www.greats-poker.com/world-series-of-poker.html free online poker free online poker http://www.greats-poker.com/free-online-poker.html poker table poker table http://www.greats-poker.com/poker-table.html world poker tour world poker tour http://www.greats-poker.com/world-poker-tour.html video poker video poker http://www.greats-poker.com/video-poker.html free texas hold em free texas hold em http://www.greats-poker.com/free-texas-hold-em.html free poker games free poker games http://www.greats-poker.com/free-poker-games.html how to play poker how to play poker http://www.greats-poker.com/how-to-play-poker.html poker hand rankings poker hand rankings http://www.greats-poker.com/poker-hand-rankings.html celebrity poker celebrity poker http://www.greats-poker.com/celebrity-poker-.html ... Thanks!!!
Posted by: poker table on June 26, 2005 07:10 PM
Please take a look at the sites in the field of poker 7 stud tournament poker 7 stud tournament http://www.e-poker-4u.net/poker-7-stud-tournament.html software poker stud 8 or better software poker stud 8 or better http://www.e-poker-4u.net/software-poker-stud-8-or-better.html 888poker stud eight 888poker stud eight http://www.e-poker-4u.net/888poker-stud-eight.html internet omaha hi internet omaha hi http://www.e-poker-4u.net/internet-omaha-hi.html holdem book review com holdem book review com http://www.e-poker-4u.net/holdem-book-review-com.html 8 or better omaha no download poker 8 or better omaha no download poker http://www.e-poker-4u.net/8-or-better-omaha-no-download-poker.html design plans for a poker table design plans for a poker table http://www.e-poker-4u.net/design-plans-for-a-poker-table.html poker 7 stud best hands contests poker 7 stud best hands contests http://www.e-poker-4u.net/poker-7-stud-best-hands-contests.html poker omaha high on the web poker omaha high on the web http://www.e-poker-4u.net/poker-omaha-high-on-the-web.html caribean stud poker stratagey caribean stud poker stratagey http://www.e-poker-4u.net/caribean-stud-poker-stratagey.html texes holdem texes holdem http://www.e-poker-4u.net/texes-holdem.html poker holdem poker holdem http://www.e-poker-4u.net/poker-holdem.html 7 card download poker 7 card download poker http://www.e-poker-4u.net/7-card-download-poker.html pacific poker omaha high tournament pacific poker omaha high tournament http://www.e-poker-4u.net/pacific-poker-omaha-high-tournament.html 7 cards stud pokerstrip 7 cards stud pokerstrip http://www.e-poker-4u.net/7-cards-stud-pokerstrip.html adult poker 1999 adult poker 1999 http://www.e-poker-4u.net/adult-poker-1999.html pokervideo over the net pokervideo over the net http://www.e-poker-4u.net/pokervideo-over-the-net.html bunny poker bunny poker http://www.e-poker-4u.net/bunny-poker.html 7 stud h l tournament 7 stud h l tournament http://www.e-poker-4u.net/7-stud-h-l-tournament.html 8 or better stud poker 8 or better stud poker http://www.e-poker-4u.net/8-or-better-stud-poker.html poker888 7 cards stud poker888 7 cards stud http://www.e-poker-4u.net/poker888-7-cards-stud.html poker variations poker variations http://www.e-poker-4u.net/poker-variations.html holdem software holdem software http://www.e-poker-4u.net/holdem-software.html poker hands order poker hands order http://www.e-poker-4u.net/poker-hands-order.html play strip poker play strip poker http://www.e-poker-4u.net/play-strip-poker.html poker empire freeroll matches poker empire freeroll matches http://www.e-poker-4u.net/poker-empire-freeroll-matches.html poker freeroll game poker freeroll game http://www.e-poker-4u.net/poker-freeroll-game.html stud 8 or better shareware poker stud 8 or better shareware poker http://www.e-poker-4u.net/stud-8-or-better-shareware-poker.html 888poker hold em 888poker hold em http://www.e-poker-4u.net/888poker-hold-em.html free rolls poker free rolls poker http://www.e-poker-4u.net/free-rolls-poker.html - Tons of interesdting stuff!!!
Posted by: poker omaha on June 27, 2005 03:21 AM
Take your time to take a look at some helpful info about blackjack blackjack http://www.epraha.info/blackjack.html .
Posted by: online gambling on June 28, 2005 02:07 AM
You can also check some relevant pages about loans loans http://www.highest-credit.com/loans.html home loans home loans http://www.highest-credit.com/home-loans.html payday loans payday loans http://www.highest-credit.com/payday-loans.html home equity loan home equity loan http://www.highest-credit.com/home-equity-loan.html payday loan payday loan http://www.highest-credit.com/payday-loan.html refinance refinance http://www.highest-credit.com/refinance.html personal loans personal loans http://www.highest-credit.com/personal-loans.html debt consolidation loan debt consolidation loan http://www.highest-credit.com/debt-consolidation-loan.html payday advance payday advance http://www.highest-credit.com/payday-advance.html credit card offers credit card offers http://www.highest-credit.com/credit-card-offers.html .
Posted by: home loans on June 28, 2005 07:36 PM
You are invited to check out some helpful info dedicated to online poker online poker http://www.poker-places.net/online-poker.html poker rooms poker rooms http://www.poker-places.net/poker-rooms.html poker poker http://www.poker-places.net/poker.html party poker party poker http://www.poker-places.net/party-poker.html pacific poker pacific poker http://www.poker-places.net/pacific-poker.html empire poker empire poker http://www.poker-places.net/empire-poker.html poker games poker games http://www.poker-places.net/poker-games.html ... Thanks!!!
Posted by: poker rooms on June 29, 2005 02:12 AM
In your free time, take a look at the pages dedicated to strip poker strip poker http://www.poker-boulevard.com/strip-poker.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/strip-poker.html play free poker for fun play free poker for fun http://www.poker-boulevard.com/play-free-poker-for-fun.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/play-free-poker-for-fun.html crazy game of poker crazy game of poker http://www.poker-boulevard.com/crazy-game-of-poker.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/crazy-game-of-poker.html poker sets poker sets http://www.poker-boulevard.com/poker-sets.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/poker-sets.html online poker tournament online poker tournament http://www.poker-boulevard.com/online-poker-tournament.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/online-poker-tournament.html party poker party poker http://www.poker-boulevard.com/party-poker.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/party-poker.html poker supplies poker supplies http://www.poker-boulevard.com/poker-supplies.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/poker-supplies.html holdem poker holdem poker http://www.poker-boulevard.com/holdem-poker.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/holdem-poker.html throat pokers throat pokers http://www.poker-boulevard.com/throat-pokers.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/throat-pokers.html online poker site online poker site http://www.poker-boulevard.com/online-poker-site.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/online-poker-site.html poker poker http://www.poker-boulevard.com/poker.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/poker.html holdem holdem http://www.poker-boulevard.com/holdem.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/holdem.html world poker tour world poker tour http://www.poker-boulevard.com/world-poker-tour.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/world-poker-tour.html online poker rooms online poker rooms http://www.poker-boulevard.com/online-poker-rooms.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/online-poker-rooms.html absolute poker absolute poker http://www.poker-boulevard.com/absolute-poker.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/absolute-poker.html star poker star poker http://www.poker-boulevard.com/star-poker.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/star-poker.html poker rules poker rules http://www.poker-boulevard.com/poker-rules.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/poker-rules.html online strip poker online strip poker http://www.poker-boulevard.com/online-strip-poker.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/online-strip-poker.html poker tables poker tables http://www.poker-boulevard.com/poker-tables.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/poker-tables.html poker tournament poker tournament http://www.poker-boulevard.com/poker-tournament.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/poker-tournament.html poker hand rankings poker hand rankings http://www.poker-boulevard.com/poker-hand-rankings.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/poker-hand-rankings.html poker table poker table http://www.poker-boulevard.com/poker-table.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/poker-table.html poker supply poker supply http://www.poker-boulevard.com/poker-supply.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/poker-supply.html internet poker internet poker http://www.poker-boulevard.com/internet-poker.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/internet-poker.html play poker play poker http://www.poker-boulevard.com/play-poker.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/play-poker.html online poker game online poker game http://www.poker-boulevard.com/online-poker-game.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/online-poker-game.html poker party poker party http://www.poker-boulevard.com/poker-party.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/poker-party.html free poker games free poker games http://www.poker-boulevard.com/free-poker-games.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/free-poker-games.html empire poker empire poker http://www.poker-boulevard.com/empire-poker.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/empire-poker.html poker cards poker cards http://www.poker-boulevard.com/poker-cards.html http://www.poker-boulevard.com/poker-cards.html .
Posted by: world series of poker on July 2, 2005 11:46 AM
Posted by: blackjack on July 4, 2005 06:30 PM
You can also visit some relevant information on poker poker http://www.poker-4all.com/poker.html http://www.poker-4all.com/poker.html poker games poker games http://www.poker-4all.com/poker-games.html http://www.poker-4all.com/poker-games.html ... Thanks!!!
Posted by: online poker on July 6, 2005 12:04 PM